Building multi-stakeholder coalitions to strengthen FLEGT in Africa

Other completed projects:

Forest law enforcement, governance and trade (FLEGT) processes in West and Central Africa, particularly the negotiation of Voluntary Partnership Agreements (VPAs), are revealing strong demand for information and participation. With the right combination of technical support and facilitation, multi-stakeholder dialogue can go far towards satisfying this demand. In fact, it is proving to be a prerequisite for successful policy making and delivery.

Between 2007 and 2010, with a grant from the UK’s Department for International Development, IUCN helped to inform and improve multi-stakeholder FLEGT dialogues in five West and Central African countries. A sixth country, China, was engaged in this project as a major consumer of timber from Africa, chiefly the Congo basin (see map opposite).

By harnessing its members, partners and projects (such as Strengthening Voices for Better Choices), and by linking up with regional initiatives and bodies (such as COMIFAC), IUCN was able to contribute to four main outcomes:

1. Successful negotiation of widely supported VPAs in Cameroon, Ghana and the Republic of Congo.

In each country, the project helped to support and facilitate studies, meetings, awareness sessions and other aspects of the VPA negotiations. It put special emphasis on informing and consulting with smaller, weaker stakeholders such as rural communities. In Ghana, IUCN played a key facilitating role throughout the VPA negotiations, stressing the importance of a long-term vision and strategy for multi-stakeholder participation. And, as Ghana moved into implementing its VPA in late 2008, the project supported studies of the agreement’s implications for community forests and its required social safeguards. Today IUCN continues to play an advisory role in the implementation of Ghana’s VPA.

2. Creation of a precedent and experience for multi-stakeholder dialogues in forest governance reform.

The project’s actions and messages consistently sought to reinforce the role of multi-stakeholder consultation in governance reforms. Some still find this role hard to understand and appreciate, even in relatively open societies such as Ghana. Despite this, beneficiaries in Ghana, Cameroon, Republic of Congo and other countries expressed support for multi-stakeholder approaches and a desire to use them in related contexts, for example national REDD preparatory processes. At the same time, IUCN was able through the project to clarify and communicate the roles it can play in multi-stakeholder processes of reform (see Box 1).

Box 1: IUCN's role in forest governance reform processes

IUCN’s experience with the Building Multi-Stakeholder Coalitions project, SVBC and other initiatives has highlighted that within each of the broad stakeholder groups of government, private sector and civil society there are often widely diverging interests. So results-driven consultation cannot mean having a few individuals at the table at one event, but reaching out to and engaging key constituencies in an ongoing process. A brief published in October 2009 outlines the specific roles IUCN can play in supporting such consultation. In any particular setting, IUCN’s precise role is determined after thorough consultation with stakeholders and adapted to the circumstances of the country and process, including local needs, the range of stakeholders and their existing relations. It also responds to IUCN’s membership in that country, whom IUCN works with and supports.

Download the brief here

3. Laying the groundwork for VPA negotiations in DR Congo.

IUCN worked with key government, business, civil society and media actors in DR Congo to raise awareness and stimulate a national dialogue on FLEGT issues and their implications. The project organised a coordinated media campaign against illegal logging using radio, television and newspapers. It also supported studies and dialogues on the timber trade in the east of the country and artisanal logging, the latter leading to the formation of a national working group on artisanal logging to recommend regulatory changes. In early 2010, DR Congo formally requested negotiations on a VPA with the European Union.

4. The emerging Africa–China dialogue on forest governance in the Congo basin.

IUCN expended – and continues to expend – great effort in strengthening Africa–China links in the forest sector. Throughout the project, IUCN facilitated learning and information exchanges between Chinese and African stakeholders, including a study tour for Chinese officials in 2008 (see Box 2). It also reached out to Chinese embassies in project countries, seeking to inform them about FLEGT issues. In China, the project’s support to the EU–China Conference on FLEG in 2007, the Chatham House dialogues on China’s global forest products trade, and translating and disseminating key documents in Chinese (such as the European Union’s FLEGT Briefing Notes), helped to engage domestic audiences in FLEGT issues.

Box 2: Promoting China's engagement in Africa

Between 24 April and 10 May 2008, a group of 7 officials from China’s State Forest Administration (SFA) and Ministry of Commerce toured Ghana, DR Congo and Gabon. Besides visiting forest concessions and processing facilities, the delegation also held lively discussions with government, industry and civil society representatives in each country. The tour had two main results: 1) a better understanding among participants of the needs and constraints of improving forest governance in specific countries; and 2) the identification of several options for further strengthening forest sector cooperation between China and Africa. As one follow-up to this tour, in March 2010 IUCN supported the participation of two SFA officials in the 3rd Racewood meeting in Douala, Cameroon, and a linked COMIFAC/CBFP workshop on FLEGT.

Download the report of study tour here

If you'd like more details on this project, please contact the IUCN Forest Conservation Programme at forests@iucn.org.

Epiphyte of Borneo
  • Wood exports from the Congo basin. The Building Multi-Stakeholder Coalitions project worked in Ghana, DR Congo, Republic of Congo, Cameroon, Gabon and China (a seventh country, Liberia, was withdrawn after some activities in 2008). Map modified by IUCN from original UNEP/GRID-Arendal source.

    Wood exports from the Congo basin. The Building Multi-Stakeholder Coalitions project worked in Ghana, DR Congo, Republic of Congo, Cameroon, Gabon and China (a seventh country, Liberia, was withdrawn after some activities in 2008). Map modified by IUCN from original UNEP/GRID-Arendal source.

    Photo: Riccardo Pravettoni

FLEG DOCUMENTS DATABASE

A complete collection of outputs from this project is being added to IUCN’s forest governance documents database. This also holds documents from the recently completed project Strengthening Voices for Better Choices (SVBC). Most of the documents in the database can be freely downloaded in PDF format.

Click here to start browsing the database.